Aerial view of an industrial plant with large round storage tanks and complex piping systems.
Automation ExcellenceFood IndustryMESUncategorized

An off-the-shelf MES? There’s no such thing!

An off-the-shelf MES? There’s no such thing!

Why standard MES systems fall short in the real world. Why existing solutions are overkill for Food manufacturers. And why a tailored, scalable solution is long overdue.

Install the MES, turn it on, and it’s up and running? Sounds good. But it doesn’t work that way. No two food processing facilities are alike—and that’s why you can’t just pull an MES off the shelf. Different machines, control systems, ERP systems, and workflows that have evolved over decades make every situation unique. Add to that industry-specific requirements—such as IFS, HACCP, or allergen management—that an MES must support—but not every system is capable of doing so.
No more half-baked knowledge and overpriced compromises. Here’s an unvarnished stocktaking of the current state of affairs—and a clear look at what an MES really needs to deliver in the Food Industry.

Every business is different. Every MES must be, too.

Heterogeneous machine fleets, different ERP and QM systems, and an IT architecture that’s unique to each customer—anyone who thinks they can get by with a standard integration is wasting their investment. Added to this are industry-specific requirements such as IFS, HACCP, or allergen management, which not every system is capable of supporting.

Heterogeneous
machine fleets

Different manufacturers, model years, and protocols require custom integrations—a standard interface is not enough.

Industry-Specific regulations

IFS, HACCP, allergen management, best-before date monitoring—the Food Industry has requirements that generic systems do not address.

Evolving IT environments

ERP, WMS, QM systems—each customer has a different setup and different integration. The complexity of the interfaces determines success or failure.

Custom workflows & shadow processes

Over the years, every plant has developed its own processes—often undocumented, but critical to operations. A MES must understand these processes before it can support them.

Process manufacturing ≠ Piece-by-Piece manufacturing

Batches, quantities, fluid processes—the logic of food production differs fundamentally from discrete manufacturing.

The illusion of the standard MES.

MES systems are based on international standards such as ISA-95 or the VDI 5600 guideline. That is correct and important. But a standard framework is not the same as a standard solution. And that is precisely where the misunderstanding lies.
Most of the systems available on the market originate from discrete manufacturing—automotive, mechanical engineering, and electronics. They operate in environments with clearly defined production volumes and cycle times. The Food Industry operates differently: complex allergen management, best-before date monitoring for perishable raw materials, Batch Traceability in fluid processes, and quality levels that determine the production sequence. All of this can only be implemented with a generic system at considerable expense.

“And this is exactly where it gets expensive: as soon as you have to deviate from the standard, customization costs skyrocket. In the end, customizing a standard system is often more time-consuming than a solution developed from the ground up to fit your exact needs. ”

Frederic DornProjektleiter planemos MES

Big, bigger, oversized? Where existing solutions reach their limits.

Many of the established MES systems were developed for large corporations with highly complex, multi-stage production structures. They offer an enormous range of features—of which medium-sized food companies typically need only a fraction.
The result: high implementation costs, long project timelines, complicated operation, and operating costs that are out of proportion to the actual benefits. The system is there—but it doesn’t fit.
  • to overload
  • too complex
  • too static
  • too expensive
  • not customizable enough

When the shop floor and management are talking past each other

MES projects rarely fail because of the technology—but because of expectations. Management wants key metrics, ROI, and predictability. The shop floor wants ease of use and a lighter workload. What’s sold as transparency at the top is perceived as surveillance at the bottom. If you don’t get all departments on board during implementation, you won’t get an MES—you’ll end up with a source of conflict.

Scalable and customizable—Why the two go hand in hand

An MES must be able to grow with the business—without having to do everything at once. First order management, then batch traceability, then OEE. Step by step, rather than all at once. At the same time, every department needs its own views and permissions. Without a flexible role and permission structure, any MES becomes a bottleneck. Modular means: lean, affordable, and still just right.

”The ERP system thinks in a completely different way than the production department. At the same time, these two levels need to communicate with each other. We understand both sides and act as the interpreter that brings them together.

Thomas BuxGeschäftsführer planemos

Nothing works without a reliable connection

Even the best MES logic is useless if data doesn’t flow smoothly. Without seamless integration with ERP, machines, and peripheral devices, data silos, manual interventions, and inconsistent information will result. The MES is then limited to partial functions and cannot deliver true transparency or process optimization across the entire production process.
Existing machines, control systems, and in-house developments play a major role in determining the complexity of the MES architecture. Systems from different manufacturers, protocols, and interfaces must be integrated, and consistent data collection must be ensured. It is crucial that all systems provide the information relevant to the MES consistently and at the required quality level.

”If you don't know the destination, you can't find the way.

Thomas BuxGeschäftsführer planemos

The MES that fits your food production needs.

No unnecessary baggage. No dependencies. A modular MES that grows with your business and pays for itself in less than 2 years.
Discover planemos MES

The right approach: Think first, then MES

Before we get into features and modules, we need to get the basics right. Companies should first clearly understand their own production processes, data flows, and objectives. Anything else is just blind action—and ultimately costs more than it’s worth.
1

Define clear objectives

2

Develop a concept in collaboration with relevant stakeholders

3

Select the appropriate modules for the system solution

4

Work out the details with the MES provider and your own process managers

planemos MES – The custom-tailored MES for the Food Industry.

planemos MES is based on practical experience gained from real-world automation and implementation projects—and is specifically tailored to the needs of the Food Industry.

”We didn't reinvent the MES wheel. We just put it on the right track.

Frederic DornProjektleiter planemos MES
“Thanks to our expertise in the industries, we focus on the features that are actually needed in a day-to-day production environment. No bloated software suites, no unnecessary features that only look good on paper. Instead: a modular, streamlined system that delivers exactly what’s needed—and scales as requirements change.”
Installing planemos MES isn’t something you can do with the push of a button. It depends on your machinery, the complexity of system integration, how well the systems have been maintained so far, and coordination with all stakeholders. But that’s exactly why we’re here. We understand food production, its challenges, and its unique characteristics—and we build the right solution based on that understanding. Compatible with all common ERP systems. On-premises for the highest data protection requirements. Modular, scalable, and backed by our own development department, which provides fast, solution-oriented support.”
Learn more about planemos MES

Less than 2 years average payback period

Modular and flexible to meet your needs

Real-Time monitoring of your production

Conclusion

A one-size-fits-all solution isn’t the answer. A custom fit is.

There’s no such thing as an off-the-shelf MES—and that’s a good thing. After all, every manufacturing facility is unique. What matters is a system that understands and reflects this uniqueness and generates real added value from it. Anyone investing in an MES today shouldn’t look for the system with the widest range of features, but rather the one that’s the best fit. They should look for a partner who knows the industry, understands the processes, and delivers a system that’s tailored to their specific production from day one. That’s exactly what planemos MES stands for.

Are you looking for an MES that’s perfectly suited to your food production process?

Then we have just the thing for you. Book a no-obligation consultation now.

  • Let’s work together to identify your company’s needs
  • A first look at our planemos MES
  • Let’s answer your questions and discuss possible next steps
Lächelnder Mann mit blonden Haaren, Bart und verschränkten Armen vor weißem Hintergrund.

Frederic Dorn

Email: hub@planemos.de
Phone: +49 9131 92 796 0

Get in touch with us

Come have a cup of coffee with us